How to Stand Out in a Crowded Holiday Market: Finding Your Authentic Brand Voice
The Holiday Marketing Noise is Already Deafening
Open your inbox. Scroll through Instagram. Check your Facebook feed.
What do you see? A sea of "Holiday Sale!" and "Black Friday Deals!" messages that all blend together in a homogeneous blur of red and green. Yep, for me that’s how I know the Christmas period is here.
As we move deeper into November, the marketing noise will only get louder. And if you're a brand trying to capture attention during this crucial selling season, there's a sobering truth you need to face:
Generic holiday marketing doesn't just underperform — it actively damages your brand.
When your messaging sounds like everyone else's, you train your audience to see you as a commodity. And commodities compete on price, not value.
But there's good news: The very thing that will set you apart this holiday season isn't a clever discount strategy or a flashy campaign. It's something you already possess: your authentic brand voice.
Why Most Holiday Marketing Falls Flat
Before we dive into finding your authentic voice, let's understand why so much holiday marketing fails to connect:
1. It Focuses on the Seller, Not the Buyer
Most holiday messaging centers around what the brand is offering: "Our biggest sale of the year!" or "Don't miss these amazing deals!"
But here's what your audience is really thinking: "How does this help me create the holiday experience I want?"
2. It Relies on Seasonal Clichés
Snowflakes, jingle bells, and "season's greetings" might feel festive, but they're so overused that they've lost their impact. Your audience has developed banner blindness to these visual and verbal clichés.
3. It Abandons Brand Personality for Holiday Cheer
Many brands completely shelve their usual tone of voice in November and December, suddenly adopting a "jolly" persona that feels disconnected from their year-round identity.
This creates cognitive dissonance for your audience. If they're used to your straightforward, no-nonsense approach all year, a sudden shift to cutesy holiday language feels inauthentic.
Finding Your Authentic Holiday Voice: A 5-Step Process
So how do you cut through the noise while staying true to your brand? Follow this five-step process to discover your authentic holiday voice:
Step 1: Identify Your Core Brand Personality Traits
Every brand has personality traits that define how it communicates. Is your brand:
Playful and spontaneous?
Sophisticated and exclusive?
Warm and nurturing?
Direct and solution-focused?
Quirky and unconventional?
Choose the 3-4 traits that most accurately describe your brand's personality. These are your non-negotiables—the qualities that should shine through in all your communications, holiday season included.
Step 2: Translate Your Brand Traits Into Holiday Context
Now, consider how these personality traits would naturally express themselves in a holiday context.
For example:
A playful brand might approach the holidays with childlike wonder
A sophisticated brand might focus on curated experiences and meaningful traditions
A warm brand might emphasize connection and gathering
A direct brand might cut through the sentimentality with practical solutions
A quirky brand might subvert holiday expectations with unexpected twists
Real-World Example:
Aesop, the skincare brand known for its sophisticated, intellectual approach, doesn't suddenly start using glitter and exclamation points during the holidays. Instead, they offer "Seasonal Formulations" in minimalist packaging with literary references — perfectly aligned with their year-round brand voice, just adapted for the season.
Step 3: Examine Your Customer's Holiday Experience
Your holiday messaging should address your customer's actual experience—not the idealized version often portrayed in media.
Ask yourself:
What specific challenges does my customer face during the holidays?
What are they trying to achieve or experience?
How do they feel during this time? (Stressed? Excited? Overwhelmed? Nostalgic?)
What role does my product or service play in their holiday experience?
Real-World Example:
A women's clothing brand might recognize that their customers aren't just shopping for "holiday outfits". They're looking for something that makes them feel confident at the office party where they'll see colleagues who've been judging their Zoom appearance for months. That specific understanding transforms generic holiday messaging into something that genuinely resonates.
Step 4: Create Your Holiday Voice Guidelines
Now, create clear guidelines for your holiday communications by completing these statements:
"During the holidays, our brand sounds..."
"During the holidays, our brand never sounds..."
"Our holiday content always includes..."
"Our holiday content never includes..."
"The one emotion we want our holiday messaging to evoke is..."
These guidelines will keep your team aligned and prevent the common slide into generic holiday messaging.
Step 5: Develop Holiday-Specific Message Frameworks
Finally, create templates for your most common holiday messages that reflect your authentic brand voice.
For example, if you're announcing a sale, how would YOUR brand specifically phrase it?
Generic Brand: "Holiday Sale! 20% off everything!"
Sophisticated Brand: "Our curated holiday collection, now with complimentary gift wrapping and 20% savings."
Playful Brand: "We're sprinkling a little magic on your holiday shopping — everything's 20% off!"
Direct Brand: "Skip the holiday shopping stress. 20% off everything. No code needed."
See how each conveys the same information but feels distinctly different?
Real Examples: Holiday Messages That Stand Out
Let's look at how these principles translate into actual holiday messaging:
Email Subject Lines
Generic: "Black Friday Deals Inside!"
Authentic Alternatives:
Warm brand: "The gifts they'll still be talking about next year"
Quirky brand: "Black Friday is coming. We're doing it differently."
Direct brand: "No hype. No gimmicks. Just honest savings."
Social Media Captions
Generic: "Get in the holiday spirit with our festive new collection! 🎄✨"
Authentic Alternatives:
Sophisticated brand: "Thoughtfully designed pieces for the moments that matter this season."
Playful brand: "Presents for adults who are just grown-up kids with money and freedom."
Nurturing brand: "Because you deserve something special after creating magic for everyone else."
Product Descriptions
Generic: "The perfect gift for everyone on your list!"
Authentic Alternatives:
Direct brand: "Guaranteed to arrive before December 24th. One less thing to worry about."
Quirky brand: "For the person who has everything (except this very specific thing)."
Sophisticated brand: "Artfully crafted for those who appreciate the exceptional."
The Competitive Advantage of Authenticity
When every other brand is shouting the same holiday messages, your authentic voice becomes your most powerful differentiator.
It cuts through the noise not by being louder, but by being distinctly you — speaking directly to your ideal customer in a way that resonates with both your brand identity and their holiday reality.
This approach does more than just improve your holiday sales (though it will do that). It also strengthens your brand equity, deepens customer loyalty, and creates momentum that carries into the new year.
Finding Your Voice: The Brand Personality Quiz
Not sure exactly what your authentic brand voice sounds like? You're not alone. Many women-led brands struggle to articulate what makes their communication style unique.
That's why I've created the Brand Personality Quiz — a free assessment that helps you identify your core brand attributes and translate them into a distinctive communication style.
In just 5 minutes, you'll discover:
Your primary and secondary brand personality traits
How these traits should inform your communication style
Common pitfalls to avoid based on your brand personality
Specific language patterns that will reinforce your unique voice
Take the Free Brand Personality Quiz
Once you understand your authentic brand voice, you'll approach the holiday marketing season with clarity and confidence, creating messages that truly resonate with your ideal customers.
Your Holiday Marketing Doesn't Have to Be Generic
As the holiday marketing noise grows louder, remember that you don't need to shout to be heard. You just need to speak authentically in a voice that's unmistakably yours.
Start by taking the Brand Personality Quiz today, and approach this holiday season with a communication strategy as unique as your brand.
the author
Hi, I’m Melody! I help women-led brands make money with copy that reflects their true brand personality and speaks directly to their audience’s hearts.
categories
search
